KACD
Articles
- Page Path
- HOME > Restor Dent Endod > Volume 33(4); 2008 > Article
- Original Article Comparative analysis of various corrosive environmental conditions for NiTi rotary files
- Ji-Wan Yum, Jeong-Kil Park, Bock Hur, Hyeon-Cheol Kim
-
Journal of Korean Academy of Conservative Dentistry 2008;33(4):377-388.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5395/JKACD.2008.33.4.377
Published online: July 31, 2008
Department of Conservative Dentistry, School of Dentistry Pusan National University, Korea.
- Corresponding Author: Hyeon-Cheol Kim. Department of Conservative Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Pusan National University, 1-10, Ami-Dong, Seo-Gu, Busan, 602-739, Korea. Tel: 82-51-240-7978, golddent@pusan.ac.kr
• Received: April 14, 2008 • Revised: May 16, 2008 • Accepted: June 9, 2008
Copyright © 2008 The Korean Academy of Conservative Dentistry
- 15 Views
- 0 Download
Abstract
-
The aim of the present study is to compare the corrosion tendency using two kinds of NiTi files in the various environmental conditions through the visual examination and electrochemical analysis. ProTaper Universal S2, 21 mm (Dentsply Maillefer, Ballaigues, Switzerland) and Hero 642, 0.06 tapers, size 25, 21 mm (Micromega, Besancon, France) rotary instruments were tested. The instruments were randomly divided into eighteen groups (n = 5) by the immersion temperature, the type of solution, the brand of NiTi rotary instrument and the presence of mechanical loading. Each file was examined at various magnifications using Scanning Electron Microscope (JEOL, Akishima, Tokyo, Japan) equipped with energy dispersive X-ray microanalysis (EDX). EDX was used to determine the components of the endodontic file alloy in corroded and noncorroded areas. The corrosion resistance of unused and used NiTi files after repeated uses in the human teeth was evaluated electrochemically by potentiodynamic polarization test using a potentiostat (Applied Corrosion Monitoring, Cark-in-Cartmel, UK).Solution temperature and chloride ion concentration may affect on passivity of NiTi files. Under the conditions of this in vitro study, the corrosion resistance is slightly increased after clinical use.
I. INTRODUCTION
The goal of root canal treatment is to achieve a high standard of disinfection of the root canal system through chemo-mechanical instrumentation1,2). with the uses of sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) and Nickel-Titanium (NiTi) rotary instruments3,4).
While the introduction of NiTi rotary instruments into endodontics has provided the benefit with characteristics of super-elasticity and high strength, their separation during root canal shaping has been a great concern5). NiTi rotary instruments usually fracture through two mechanisms: torsion or metal fatigue caused by flexure6,7). Fracture caused by fatigue failure mechanism occurs due to crack initiation on the cutting surfaces and propagation toward the file's axial center8-10).
Recently, the influence of NaOCl on the corrosion of NiTi rotary instruments has been studied11). It is known that NaOCl, a chlorine-containing solution, is corrosive to metals. Corrosion adversely affects the metallic surfaces by causing pitting and porosity, and decreases the cutting efficiency of endodontic files. Pitting corrosion is initiated by localized chemical or mechanical damage to the protective oxide film. It is supposed that the micropitting acts as microstructural defects for the crack formation and stress risers12). Also, corrosion fatigue may be initiated at the base of corrosion pits. Corrosion-fatigue is the result of the combined action of alternating or cycling stresses and corrosive environment13). The fatigue process is thought to cause rupture of the protective passive film, upon which corrosion is accelerated.
It is well known that NiTi alloys have corrosion resistance thanks to the surface film of titanium oxide14). The passive film acts as protective coating to protect the underlying surface from further chemical reaction, such as corrosion, electrodissolution, or dissolution. The passivation of metal is affected by many factors like solution temperature, composition of material, and chloride ion concentration.
The influence of NaOCl on the corrosion of NiTi rotary instruments has been studied and the results by various authors are contradictory15-19). Significant signs of surface corrosion were reported by O'Hoy and colleagues20) after overnight immersion, whereas Darabara et al.21) found no signs of corrosion after immersion for 1 hour in 5.25% NaOCl and 17% ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) heated to 37℃. The inconsistent results are due mainly to the different study conditions and interpretations. There is no report about the corrosion of the NiTi rotary instruments after chemo-mechanical preparation and cleaning procedure using NaOCl solution in the root canals of human teeth.
Therefore, the purpose of the present study is to evaluate the corrosion resistance of used and unused NiTi files in the various environmental conditions through the microstructural observation of optical and Scanning Electron Microscpoe (SEM) examination and electrochemical analysis.
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS
A total of 45 ProTaper Universal S2, 21 mm (Dentsply Maillefer, Ballaigues, Switzerland) and 45 Hero 642, 0.06 tapers, size 25, 21 mm (Micromega, Besancon, France) rotary instruments were tested.
The instruments were randomly divided into eighteen groups (n = 5). Two groups (HC and PC) were assigned as the control group (negative control group; no exposure to any environment) and sixteen groups (H1~H8 and P1~P8) were divided by the conditions such as immersion temperature, the type of solution, the brand of NiTi rotary instrument and the presence of mechanical loading (Table 1).
Extracted fifty maxillary and mandibular human molars were used to simulate clinical conditions. The irrigating solutions used were commercial 5.25 wt% NaOCl and distilled water; both solutions were prepared just before instrumentation. The instruments were driven by an electronic motor (X-smart; Dentsply Maillefer, Ballaigues, Switzerland) set at 300 rpm and torque of 2.4 N. The mechanical preparation of 20 root canals for each file was done without lubricant at room temperature (21 ± 2℃).
After shaping each canal, the files were placed in a separate glass vials filled with 10 ml of the 5.25 w% NaOCl solution or distilled water for overnight (18 h). Vials were either stored at room temperature (22℃) or were placed in an electronically controlled heating device (Multiblock 2001; Labline, Mehare Park, IL, USA) after the preset immersion temperature of 55℃ had been reached. Before microstructural evaluation, the files were cleaned in an ultrasonic bath with distilled water and air dried.
Files from the control groups (unused) and experimental groups were examined for evidence of corrosion using the criteria of shown in Table 2. Precipitated corrosion products were identified as a precipitate within the solution or deposited on the metal surface.
After optical microscope (OPMI pico; Carl zeiss, Obercohen, Germany) assessment of corrosion, each file was examined at various magnifications using Scanning Electron Microscope (JEOL, Akishima, Tokyo, Japan) equipped with energy dispersive X-ray microanalysis (EDX). EDX was used to determine the components of the endodontic file alloy in corroded and noncorroded areas.
Statistical analysis of the collected data was performed with SAS version 9.1. Log-linear model (Poisson regression) was used to exam the effect of explanatory variable (experimental conditions) to dependent variable (score) (Table 5). The differences revealed in the data were designated as significant at p < .05.
The corrosion resistance of unused and used NiTi files after repeated uses in the human teeth was evaluated electrochemically by potentiodynamic polarization test using a potentiostat (Applied Corrosion Monitoring, Cark-in-Cartmel, UK). A platinum wire was employed as a counter electrode. The reference electrode employed was an Ag / AgCl electrode with an electrochemical potential of -16 mV with respect to the saturated calomel electrode (SCE). All potentials in the text refer to the SCE, which is +242 mV with respect to the normal hydrogen electrode (NHE). The NaOCl solution was heated to 37℃ and this temperature was held until the end of the tests. Polarization curves were obtained with a potential scan rate of 10 mV / sec.
III. RESULTS
The results of each group were summarized in Table 3 and Table 4. No obvious sign of corrosion was found on the flutes of all experimental files when immersed in distilled water and NaOCl solution at room temperature (22℃). On the other hand, general corrosion signs like changes of metal color and existence of precipitate were observed when immersed in NaOCl solution at heating temperature (55℃). This phenomenon was more evident in the ProTaper files which have metal shaft than in the Hero 642 files which have plastic shaft (Figure 1).
Through the statistical analysis using Log-linear model, among the four environmental conditions of corrosion, the storage media and the immersion temperature had affected significantly to corrosion (p < .0001) (Table 5).
After application to Log-linear model fitted offset (y = e0.7354 - 1.5041 × storage - 2.5455 t × temp), the higher fitted value was detected in the groups with high temperatures and NaOCl immersion (Table 6).
SEM showed typical patterns of torsional and fatigue failure (Figure 2A). SEM analysis of the files exposed to the room temperature NaOCl solution indicated the same morphology for all the files without any evidence of localized corrosion (Figure 2B). No difference was observed in comparison to the files as received. The degradation effect of immersion in heated NaOCl solution was clear as localized attacks both on the cutting edges and on the flat surface in the SEM images (Figure 2C and D). Data analysis showed that immersion temperature and presence of dissimilar metals had significant effects on the corrosion of NiTi rotary files. The EDX spectra revealed the similar components between the noncorroded and corroded areas of NiTi files (Figure 3).
Figure 4 (A) presents typical polarization curves of used and unused NiTi files in NaOCl reagent as logarithmic scale of current density. It can be observed that the polarization curves of two specimens showed similar results. After conjecturing the result, used file (black line) insignificantly demonstrated rather higher corrosion potential as 0.7 V than unused file (red line) (0.6 V).
Figure 4 (B) shows results of the same experiment as algebraic scale of current density. In this figure, used file indicates higher corrosion potential in excessively high potential region above 1.2 V, what is called the region of breakdown of passivity.
IV. DISCUSSION
Pitting corrosion causes metal failure by the creation of small holes in metal surfaces. Fracture caused by fatigue failure mechanism occurs due to crack initiation at the cutting surfaces22). It is generally associated with specific species in solution, by far the most common of which is chloride. Some sorts of metals are more intrinsically resistant to corrosion than others, either due to the fundamental nature of the electrochemical processes involved or due to the details of how reaction products form23). It is well known that titanium shows high corrosion resistance in an alloy to chloride compound24). Nevertheless, with the presence of chloride ions, some microscopic breakdown events can be observed on titanium at potentials far below the pitting potential.
Given the right conditions, a thin film of corrosive products can form on metal's surface spontaneously, acting as a barrier to further oxidation. Passivation is extremely useful in alleviating corrosion damage. NiTi alloys are generally passivated by the surface film of titanium and nickel oxide. The corrosion patterns of NiTi alloy involve selective removal of nickel from the surface25). Thus, it may be that after some initial dissolution of nickel from the surface, the nickel-titanium alloy may form a surface containing mainly titanium oxides in the outer layer and nickel-titanium in the inner layer26,27). Surface oxidation seems to be very promising for improving the corrosion resistance and biocompatibility of NiTi28).
Certain conditions, such as high concentrations of chloride, can interfere with a given alloy's ability to re-form a passivating film. The growth of passivating titanium oxide film involves migration of oxide ions through oxide anion vacancies. On reaching the metal / film interface, new oxide is formed at that interface. In the presence of chloride ions, it can migrate in parallel across the passivating oxide. Thus, if chloride ions reach the metal / film interface, it would form the metal chloride. If sufficient metal chloride were to accumulate there, the oxide would rupture explosively, and reveal a bare metal surface, forming a microscopically saturated chloride solution. The oxide film requires sufficient chloride accumulation at one specific spot in order for film rupture to occur.
Raising the temperature generally causes metals to pit more readily. Pit nucleation and metastable propagation have not been much examined in terms of temperature dependence. The effects of solution temperature and chloride ion concentration on the electronic properties of passive film on pure metals have been investigated for many years29). Chloride ions migrate across the passivating oxide film faster at higher temperatures. It is supposed that the concentration of oxygen and metal vacancy in the passive film has increased accompanying with it an increase of temperature and chloride ion concentration. It was noticed that the instruments immersed in heated NaOCl solution from this study produced marked visible dark particles in the solution as evidence of corrosion. Heating NaOCl solutions up to 60℃ has been suggested to increase reactivity and antimicrobial and tissue-dissolving action30). However, the increase in reactivity may also enhance the corrosive potential of commercial NaOCl solutions and adversely affect mechanical properties of NiTi rotaries. Such an effect of heating of NaOCl on NiTi file integrity was described by Peters et al31). They found a reduction in fatigue resistance after immersion in NaOCl solution for two hours at 60℃, not only for machined ProFiles but also for electropolished RaCe rotaries.
There were differences in visual corrosion appearance after immersion between unused files and used files in human teeth from this study. The potentiodynamic polarization test was done to evaluate stress factor through comparing the corrosion resistance between unused and used files in human teeth. Generally, corrosion potential value is indicative for the ionization tendency of materials in specific media. The ionization tendency is decreased towards higher corrosion potential values. There are reports suggesting that NiTi alloy cannot re-passivate itself speedily if the surface film is disrupted or damaged after contacting against the root canal wall32). However, in the present study, used files after contacting against the root canal wall several times insignificantly demonstrated rather higher corrosion potential values than unused files. According to the results of this study, NiTi files seem to have the ability to re-form the passive film after repeated clinical uses.
The other type of metal corrosion is galvanic corrosion. Galvanic corrosion occurs when two different metals electrically contact each other and are immersed in an electrolyte33). ProTaper files showed more severe corrosion appearance than hero 642 files in NaOCl solution. EDX microanalysis showed that the cutting and non-cutting sections of the ProTaper file were made of a NiTi alloy, whilst the shank was made of gold-plated brass. Otherwise, the shank of the hero 642 file was non metallic material. Thus the NiTi alloy seemed to act as the anode and the gold-coated shaft acts as the cathode in the corrosion cell when the instrument was immersed in NaOCl solution. Galvanic corrosion also occurs independently in some cases. NaOCl may be present in the pulp chambers of teeth with restorations of different metals (amalgam, gold, etc.) and NiTi files could be damaged mechanically by various metals. If the passive film is damaged mechanically, the spot acts as the anode and the other parts of the passive film acts as the cathode. When a galvanic couple forms, one of the metals in the couple becomes the anode and corrodes faster than it otherwise would, whilst the other becomes the cathode and corrodes more slowly than it would alone. One important factor influencing galvanic corrosion is area ratios of the anode and cathode34). A small anode / cathode area ratio is highly undesirable. In this case, the galvanic current is concentrated onto a small anodic area. Rapid loss of thickness of the dissolving anode tends to occur under these conditions.
As for most metallic materials, the localized corrosion behavior of NiTi alloy depends on environmental conditions and it is very hard to analyze quantitatively. EDX spectra represent qualitative analysis of the corroded region. The presence of oxides on the corroded areas in the EDX spectrum could not be the firm evidence of corrosion because of passive film products. Moreover, the verification of stress corrosion cracking and corrosion fatigue usually requires specific equipments. Further investigation will be necessary to relate corrosion and unexpected cracks in NiTi rotary endodontic instruments more closely.
V. CONCLUSIONS
Under the condition of this in vitro study, the solution temperature and chloride ion concentration had an effect on passivity of NiTi files. In addition, corrosion performance of NiTi files could be increased by galvanic corrosion with presence of dissimilar metal.
- 1. Schilder H. Filling root canals in three dimensions. Dent Clin North Am. 1967;723-744.
- 2. Schilder H. Cleaning and shaping the root canal. Dent Clin North Am. 1974;18: 269-296.PubMed
- 3. Haapasalo M, Endal U, Zandi H, Coil JM. Eradication of endodontic infection by instrumentation and irrigation solutions. Endod Top. 2005;10: 77-102.
- 4. Zehnder M. Root canal irrigants. J Endod. 2006;32: 389-398.ArticlePubMed
- 5. Walia HM, Brantley WA, Gerstein H. An initial investigation of the bending and torsional properties of nitinol root canal files. J Endod. 1988;14: 346-351.PubMed
- 6. Martín B, Zelada G, Varela P, Bahillo JG, Magán F, Ahn S, Rodríguez C. Factors influencing the fracture of nickel-titanium rotary instruments. Int Endod J. 2003;36: 262-266.PubMed
- 7. Luebke NH, Brantley WA, Alapati SB, Mitchell JC, Lausten LL, Daehn GS. Bending fatigue study of nickel-titanium Gates Glidden drills. J Endod. 2005;31: 523-525.PubMed
- 8. Sotokawa T. An analysis of clinical breakage of root canal instruments. J Endod. 1988;14: 75-82.ArticlePubMed
- 9. Kuhn G, Tavernier B, Jordan L. Influence of structure on nickel-titanium endodontic instruments failure. J Endod. 2001;27: 516-520.PubMed
- 10. Zinelis S, Margelos J. In: Lambrianidis T, editor. Assessment of fracture mechanism of endodontic files. Risk Management in Root Canal Treatment. 2001;1st edn. Thessaloniki, Greece: University Studio Press; 239-243.
- 11. Sarkar NK, Redmond W, Schwaninger B, Goldberg AJ. The chloride corrosion of four orthodontic wires. J Oral Rehabil. 1983;10: 121-128.PubMed
- 12. Oshida Y, Sachdeva RCI, Miyazaki S. Microanalytical characterization and surface modification of NiTi orthodontic arch wires. Biomed Mater Eng. 1992;2: 51-69.PubMed
- 13. International ASM. ASM handbook, fatigue and fracture. 1996;vol.19: Materials Park, OH: ASM International.
- 14. Firstov GS, Vitchev RG, Kumar H, Blanpain B, Van Humbeeck J. Surface oxidation of NiTi shape memory alloy. Biomaterials. 2002;23: 4863-4871.PubMed
- 15. Busslinger A, Sener B, Barbakow F. Effects of sodium hypochlorite on nickel-titanium lightspeed instruments. Int Endod J. 1998;31: 290-294.PubMed
- 16. Haikel Y, Serfaty R, Wilson P, Speisser JM, Allemann C. Cutting efficiency of nickel-titanium endodontic instruments and the effect of sodium hypochlorite treatment. J Endod. 1998;24: 736-739.PubMed
- 17. Haikel Y, Serfaty R, Wilson P, Speisser JM, Allemann C. Mechanical properties of nickel-titanium endodontic instruments and the effect of sodium hypochlorite treatment. J Endod. 1998;24: 731-735.ArticlePubMed
- 18. Kim H, Johnson JW. Corrosion of stainless steel, nickel-titanium, coated nickel-titanium and titanium orthodontic wires. Angle Orthod. 1999;69: 39-44.PubMed
- 19. Stokes OW, Fiore PM, Barss JT, Koerber A, Gilbert JL, Lautenschlager EP. Corrosion in stainless-steel and nickel-titanium files. J Endod. 1999;25: 17-20.ArticlePubMed
- 20. O'Hoy PYZ, Messer HH, Palamara JE. The effect of cleaning procedures on fracture properties and corrosion of NiTi files. Int Endod J. 2003;36: 724-732.PubMed
- 21. Darabara M, Bourithis L, Zinelis S, Papadimitriou GD. Susceptibility to localized corrosion of stainless steel and NiTi endodontic instruments in irrigating solutions. Int Endod J. 2004;37: 705-710.ArticlePubMed
- 22. Lee JK, Kim ES, Kang MW, Kum KY. The effect of surface defects on the cyclic fatigue fracture of HERO shaper Ni-Ti rotary files in a dynamic model: A fractographic analysis. J Korean Acad Conserv Dent. 2007;32: 130-136.Article
- 23. Huang HH. Effect of chemical composition on the corrosion behavior of Ni-Cr-Mo dental casting alloys. J Biomed Mater Res. 2002;60: 458-465.ArticlePubMed
- 24. Endo K, Sachdeva R, Araki Y, Ohno H. Effects of titanium nitride coatings on surface and corrosion characteristics of Ni-Ti alloy. Dent Mater J. 1994;13: 228-239.PubMed
- 25. Montero-Ocampo C, Lopez H, Salinas Rodriguez A. Effect of compressive straining on corrosion resistance of a shape memory Ni-Ti alloy in Ringer's solution. J Biomed Mater Res. 1996;32: 583-591.ArticlePubMed
- 26. Wever DJ, Veldhuizen AG, de Vries J, Busscher HJ, Uges DR, van Horn JR. Electrochemical and surface characterization of a nickel-titanium alloy. Biomaterials. 1998;19: 761-769.ArticlePubMed
- 27. Thierry B, Tabrizian M, Trepanier C, Savadogo O, Yahia L. Effect of surface treatment and sterilization processes on the corrosion behavior of NiTi shape memory alloy. J Biomed Mater Res. 2000;51: 685-693.ArticlePubMed
- 28. Trépanier C, Tabrizian M, Yahia LH, Bilodeau L, Piron DL. Effect of modification of oxide layer on NiTi stent corrosion resistance. J Biomed Mater Res. 1998;43: 433-440.PubMed
- 29. Burstein GT, Liu C, Souto RM. The effect of temperature on the nucleation of corrosion pits on titanium in Ringer's physiological solution. Biomaterials. 2005;26: 245-256.ArticlePubMed
- 30. Sirtes G, Waltimo T, Schaetzle M, Zehnder M. The effects of temperature on sodium hypochlorite short-term stability, pulp dissolution capacity, and antimicrobial efficacy. J Endod. 2005;31: 669-671.ArticlePubMed
- 31. Peters OA, Roehlike JO, Baumann MA. Effect of immersion in sodium hypochlorite on torque and fatigue resistance of nickel-titanium instruments. J Endod. 2007;33: 589-593.ArticlePubMed
- 32. Rondelli G, Vicentini B. Evaluation by electrochemical tests of the passive film stability of equiatomic Ni-Ti alloy also in presence of stress-induced martensite. J Biomed Mater Res. 2000;51: 47-54.PubMed
- 33. Angelini E, Zucchi F, Caputo A. In: Barbucci R, editor. Degradation processes on metallic surfaces. Integrated Biomaterial Science. 2002;Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic - Plenum Publishers; 308-323.Article
- 34. Iijima M, Endo K, Yuasa T, Ohno H, Hayashi K, Kakizaki M, Mizoguchi I. Galvanic corrosion behavior of orthodontic archwire alloys coupled to bracket alloys. Angle Orthod. 2006;76: 705-711.PubMed
REFERENCES
Figure 1
Corrosion appearance of ProTaper and Hero 642.
A; ProTaper in NaOCl at 55℃ B; Hero 642 in NaOCl at 55℃ C; ProTaper after immersing in NaOCl (left) and distilled water (right) at 55℃ D; Hero 642 after immersing in NaOCl (left) and distilled water (right) at 55℃.
Figure 2
SEM observation of NiTi files as representative of Group P2 (A), Group H5 (B), Group P8 (C), and Group H8 (D).
Figure 3
(A) EDX spectra of the Hero 642 instrument shown in Figure 2 B. The presence of Ni and Ti on the non-corroded areas is clearly seen. (B) EDX spectra of the Hero 642 instrument shown in Figure 2 D. Oxides are shown in corroded areas.
Tables & Figures
REFERENCES
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by 
ePub Link
Cite
XML DownloadComparative analysis of various corrosive environmental conditions for NiTi rotary files
Figure 1
Corrosion appearance of ProTaper and Hero 642.
A; ProTaper in NaOCl at 55℃ B; Hero 642 in NaOCl at 55℃ C; ProTaper after immersing in NaOCl (left) and distilled water (right) at 55℃ D; Hero 642 after immersing in NaOCl (left) and distilled water (right) at 55℃.
Figure 2
SEM observation of NiTi files as representative of Group P2 (A), Group H5 (B), Group P8 (C), and Group H8 (D).
Figure 3
(A) EDX spectra of the Hero 642 instrument shown in Figure 2 B. The presence of Ni and Ti on the non-corroded areas is clearly seen. (B) EDX spectra of the Hero 642 instrument shown in Figure 2 D. Oxides are shown in corroded areas.
Figure 4
Representative potentiondynamic polarization curves of tested instruments; red line - new file and black line - used file.
Figure 1
Figure 2
Figure 3
Figure 4
Comparative analysis of various corrosive environmental conditions for NiTi rotary files
Groups for experimental conditions
Scoring system for evidence of corrosion19)*
19)Stockes et al.
Frequency of corrosive scores in each group (n = 5)
The corrosive scores at each condition (mean ± S.D.)
Comparison of environmental conditions for NiTi file corrosion
**: p < .01, ***: p < .001
Comparative effectiveness of corrosive conditions
The more corrosion was detected in the groups with high temperatures and NaOCl immersion and the lesser with low temperature and Distilled water (p < .05).
Table 1
Groups for experimental conditions
Table 2
Scoring system for evidence of corrosion19)*
Table 3
Frequency of corrosive scores in each group (n = 5)
Table 4
The corrosive scores at each condition (mean ± S.D.)
Table 5
Comparison of environmental conditions for NiTi file corrosion
**: p < .01, ***: p < .001
Table 6
Comparative effectiveness of corrosive conditions
The more corrosion was detected in the groups with high temperatures and NaOCl immersion and the lesser with low temperature and Distilled water (p < .05).
