Copyright © 2012 The Korean Academy of Conservative Dentistry
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Studies on the success rate of endodontic microsurgery
Study | Sample size | Follow up period | Recall rate | Magnification | Root-end preparation | Root-end filling material | Root-end filling material | Methodology |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rubinstein & Kim(1999)32 | 128 | 14 mon | 94/128 | Microscope | Ultrasonic | Super EBA | 96.8 | Prospective |
Rubinstein & Kim(2002)41 | 91 | 5 – 7 yr | 59/91 | Microscope | Ultrasonic | Super EBA | 91.5 | Prospective |
Chong et al. (2003)16 | 122 | 1 – 2 yr | 108/122 | Microscope | Ultrasonic | MTA IRM |
92 87 |
Prospective |
Taschieri et al. (2006)18 | 80 | 1 yr | 71/80 | Endoscope Loupe | Ultrasonic | EBA | 94.9 90.6 |
RCT |
Tsesis et al. (2006)20 | 110 | > 6 mon | 88/110 | Microscope No aid | Ultrasonic Bur | IRM | 91.1 44.2 |
Retrospective |
Taschieri et al. (2007)33 | 30 | 1 yr | 28/30 | Endoscope | Ultrasonic | Super EBA | 93 | Prospective |
Von Arx et al. (2007)34 | 194 | 1 yr | 191/194 | Endoscope | Sonic | MTA, Retroplast, Super EBA | 83.8 | Prospective |
Von Arx et al. (2007)30 | 183 | 1 yr | 177/183 | Endoscope | Sonic | MTA, Super EBA | 83 | Prospective |
Taschieri et al. (2008)35 | 113 | > 2 yr | 100/113 | Microscope Endoscope | Ultrasonic | Super EBA | 92 90 |
RCT |
Saunder et al. (2008)14 | 321 | 4 – 72 mon | 276/321 | Microscope | Ultrasonic | MTA | 88.8 | Prospective |
Kim et al. (2008)8 | 263 | 1 – 5 yr | 192/263 | Microscope | Ultrasonic | MTA, Super EBA | 91.5 | Prospective |
Christiansen et al.(2009)13 | 52 | 1 yr | 46/52 | Microscope | Ultrasonic | MTA GP Smoothing |
96 52 |
RCT |
Von Arx et al. (2010)31 | 353 | 1 yr | 339/353 | Microscope | Sonic | MTA Retroplast |
91.3 79.5 |
Prospective |
Song et al. (2011)10 | 54 | 1 – 7 yr | 42/54 | Microscope | Ultrasonic | MTA, Super EBA | 92.9 | Prospective |
MTA, mineral trioxide aggregate; GP, gutta-percha; RCT, randomized controlled trial study.
MTA, mineral trioxide aggregate; GP, gutta-percha; RCT, randomized controlled trial study.